Sunday, August 14, 2011

Forgiveness

A little slip of paper is taped next to the switch on my bedside lamp.

Handwritten, is the question, "Did you leave this day better than you found it?"

Throughout the week I jot down little inspirational phrases that pop into my head, or that I hear or read. I don't know if that one was mine or someone else’s, but it is so profound that I decided it should be the last thing I see before I go to bed and the first thing I see when I wake up.

Last night, I was out with some friends in downtown Minneapolis. Every hour I had to excuse myself to go out into the cold and put another two quarters in my parking meter. One of those times, my brisk walk to the meter was interrupted by a man, wrapped head to toe in tattered winter apparel.
Read More

As soon as I stepped from the pub, I saw the man - he was about 10 feet away. My thoughts: Here we go. This guy is going ask me for money. Just don't make eye contact. Keep walking, keep walking. In a dialect of English I could barely decipher he said, "Excuse me, blah blah blah..." To which I responded with a sharp, "No thank you." I kept walking.

Another 50 feet, and I arrived at my nearly expired meter. I reached into my pocket, full of quarters, and extracted just two. I glanced back to the assailant who was now scanning the street scene for another source of funds. I inserted the quarters into the meter then lingered, glancing back, hoping that he would move along, or bother someone else, so I could return to the warmth of the pub and my friends, without another hassle.

It was cold and I was getting colder and I gave up waiting after only 10 - 15 seconds. I figured I could slip past the societal menace without incident, so I headed back.

As I approached, I noticed that he was standing in front of two identical US Mailbox receptacles. Getting closer, I saw that he was holding an envelope. "At least he's not looking at me." I thought, and I slipped right by.

I was nearly at the door, when I had a sudden urge to turn around and assess his situation a little further. On closer inspection, he appeared to be wrestling with the decision as to which mailbox to insert his letter. I inched closer and realized that in the near darkness of the sidewalk, one could barely see the instructions posted on the mailboxes.

I decided to intervene and asked, "What are you trying to do?" Pointing his letter back and forth between the openings of the two mailboxes, he said something like, "Letter, blah blah... Which one blah blah..." I realized at this point that english was not his first language. But, communication occurred. I held out my hand, offering to inspect his letter. He handed it to me. I could see that it was addressed to a medical insurance company, and properly postaged.

I took out my cell phone and activated the flashlight feature to illuminate the instructions on the mailboxes. I quickly determined that they were indeed the same and that it would not make a difference into which receptacle the letter was deposited. I pointed the letter back and forth to each mailbox and said, "Same. Same." With a great big smile on his face, he nodded his head up and down and said, "Thank you. Thank you."

Trusting me, he turned back to the mailboxs and inserted his letter into the one on the right. He turned and saw that I was still standing there. I don't know why I didn't just leave. Part of me wanted to make sure he didn't encounter any more hurdles. Just before turning away, I said, "I'm sorry about - " He interrupted by saying, "No problem. It's okay." We both knew what I had done just 60 seconds before; how I had instantly judged and shunned him. But he forgave me - just like that.

Did I leave yesterday better than I found it? I think the day left me better than it found me.

Monday, March 15, 2010

My Referral Source Don't Know Nuthin'


Every good business professional has a network of referral sources. If you don’t; get one, then come back and read this.

Welcome back, now that you have a referral network, you need to train them. This training will enhance the quality of your referrals and set their expectations at a workable level.

The goal is to get good quality referrals that have reasonable expectations when they walk through your door. Problems arise when a referral comes in with false or completely unreasonable expectations, which can get you started on an uphill battle right out of the gate. Worst of all, it can put pressure on you to perform; that is, to cut corners and force the client’s needs into a product that doesn’t exist or service that you cannot ethically provide .

Here is an example of a situation that happens far too often in the real estate finance industry:

Real estate agent Rodney meets Mr. Smith, a potential buyer, at an open house. Mr. Smith asks Rodney to tell him how much down payment he will need. Rodney says that he sold a house just like this last month and that the buyer only had to come up with 5%. Mr. Smith comments that his best friend will probably lend him the down payment money.

Mr. Smith asks what the interest rates are. Rodney says he thinks they are around 4%. Mr. Smith comments that this will be a great rental property. Rodney gives Mr. Smith your phone number (in this example, you are the loan officer). As Mr. Smith leaves the open house, Rodney says, “My loan officer will take care of you. She can get anybody approved.”

Before we blast Rodney the real estate agent, you of course need to thank him for thinking of you when it came to referring his potential customer. He is one of the reasons you are in business.

Let’s now identify the things Rodney could have done differently so that Mr. Smith would be coming to you with reasonable expectations.

When your new potential customer, Mr. Smith, shows up at your office he thinks that you are a real estate finance magician! He was told by Rodney that you can, “get anybody approved.” Hopefully this is not true. If it is, it just might mean that you are willing to cut corners and operate in the murky gray area.

That is not to say that you can’t be a good, creative finance professional. A creative professional works with their potential customers to get them into the right product using the skill and finesse of his vast base of product knowledge; not by force or misrepresentation – which are methods you might be tempted to use out of fear of loosing Rodney as a referral source.

So, Mr. Smith expects to get a loan. Not just any loan, but a loan with a 4% interest rate, to buy an investment property with a borrowed down payment of 5% or less. This is most likely, an unreasonable expectation.

Rodney, unwittingly, is setting us up for failure. He has no idea if Mr. Smith just lost his job, defaulted on his current mortgage loan and/or is in the middle of bankruptcy. While Rodney felt just fine about quoting interest rates and down payment requirements, he didn’t say anything about the common lender restrictions of borrowing a down payment, the hourly interest rate fluxuations, the loan-to-value limitations on an investment property purchase or any other guidelines.

Rodney didn’t say anything, because Rodney didn’t know. We don’t expect Rodney to know all about these things; we just want him to know some of the key things to listen for. But until you train him, you’ll need to politely ask Rodney to close his yapper.

At this initial phase of the customer’s purchasing experience, there is no way that even you could know which loan products or interest rates will work for this new customer; and Rodney, a non-finance professional, will definitely not know.

Additionally, even though we know that Rodney is not an expert in real estate finance, the customer’s perception is, most likely, different. If any of the professionals involved in the transaction tell Mr. Smith that his interest rate is going to be around 4% or that it’s okay to use 5% of borrowed money for the down payment, it’s likely that Mr. Smith will take that to the bank; and set him up with unreasonable expectations.

This brings us to the danger zone. This is when you can be tempted to bend the rules, to omit pertinent information from the file or outright lie just to get the deal done. You are tempted to do this for several reasons. 1) you don’t want to disappoint Rodney or loose future business from him, 2) you don’t want to make a liar out of Rodney – after all, he did tell Mr. Smith that you’re a loan magician, and 3) you just want to get this one loan closed for Rodney – if you have to bend the rules just this once, maybe its is no big deal.

In tough economic times, business is hard enough to come by. We want to shower our prospects with that sweet sweet customer service and do whatever we can to keep them. We all know that customers are often willing to go “across the street” to the competition; where some other finance professional is willing to cut corners to get the deal done.

Here are a few pointers for your Referral Source Training Program.

1. Let your referral sources know that you appreciate their business. This is a number 1 priority.

2. Give them an overview of the types of products and services you are capable of providing. Let them know the key indicators that could challenge your ability to deliver your product or service.

3. Tell your referral source that you are willing to keep them in the loop. There are privacy issues in many professions, so you can’t divulge the customer’s personal financial information, but an update can help your efforts in educating your referral source – if they want an update.

I’m sure you have horror stories of your own. Think of situations you’ve had with new customers who’ve come to you with unreasonable expectations. Why did this happen? What could you teach your referral source about these situations?

In the real estate finance profession (just like many others), there are tons of rules, guidelines and regulations. Again, I am not telling you to train your referral sources to be experts at what you do. It’ll take you about a half of an hour to think or read through the list of questions you ask during your initial conversation with a new customer, to come up with your little training session.

For example, you can tell Rodney that if a customer starts talking or asking questions about things like down payment, interest rates or qualifying income, he should tell the customer that you are an awesome finance professional and that you know all about that stuff.

Educate Rodney on a few big issues to listen for such as, non-owner occupancy, current state of unemployed, citizenship status, etc. When Rodney hears these types of things in his initial conversation with his customer, recommend that he say something like, “Oh, you’re going to want to mention that to the loan officer right up front.”

Make sure your referral source does not try to qualify your leads. You are the expert and can judge whether or not you can deliver, but a little bit of training for your referral source can save you a lot of potential prison time. (I always seem to be able to bring it back to something about prison)

As an added bonus, this “training” is just one more way you can get in front of your referral sources. Perhaps Rodney works for a company that has weekly or monthly meetings that you could invite yourself to. I’ve even gone as far as scripting a few different role plays; one that depicted situations of how NOT to manage a customer’s expectations and another one that showed the right way to do it.

As a team, you and Rodney can work together to make sure that the Mr. Smiths of the world have great buying experiences.

Tuesday, February 16, 2010

Fraud: Consumer v. Professional

Howell Haunson wrote a great post about spotting fraud perpetrators. Thankfully his audience was industry insiders (in this case it was mortgage and real estate industry professionals).

In many industries, education is focused on fraud spotting and "red flags" as it pertains to the consumer. That is to say that we're all worried about how to protect our companies from those bad eggs out there who are trying to pull one over on us, i.e. the mortgage, CPA or the banking professional.

This education is vitally important. There are sneaky, organized con artists that could cost your company millions. However, lets not forget - about 80% of all fraud losses are due to the collaboration or collusion of industry insiders.

So, this means that we still have to watch out for each other.

Friday, February 12, 2010

Will Your Son Wind Up In Prison?

I had the unfortunate experience of serving a little over a year in federal prison. I took notes and have come up with what I believe to be a pretty accurate profile of a would-be inmate. To those of you who are mothers and fathers, this might explain a lot!

His name is Bubba
This one can easily be avoided. There are literally tens of thousands of other names to choose from. All you have to do is pick one of these other names. Caution: think twice about choosing a girl’s name – just in case. If you’ve named your daughter Bubba – why?

Has a hairy back
Sorry to say folks but its true. Prisons are full of hairy backed men. I don’t know if children with hairy backs grow up full of anger from the years of ridicule, and then work through the resentment by committing crimes? I’m just not sure. But you’d swear the Federal Bureau of Prisons has rounded up all of the “missing links” and locked them up.

He murders a lot
This one may seem like a no-brainer, but you might be surprised at how many people commit crimes and avoid prison.

He is loud
If your boy enjoys communicating at between 110 and 120 decibels during normal conversation, beware. Look on the bright side – he’ll get to kick it up a few notches once the cell slams shut. They like LOUD there.

He snores
We’re not just looking for a light rumbling snore. Here’s a little test: Assemble two 24 oz. slabs of raw prime rib (2 inches thick, min.). Take them to the car wash and pull up to the car vacuum area. Insert the hose halfway in between the two cuts of meat. Then, turn it on. The loud, percussive flapping sound that will be created as the air is sucked through the meat sounds exactly like that of an inmate snoring. Compare this with the timbre of your son’s snoring. Check!

He is an idiot
I’m not saying that your kid is doomed if he gets Ds or even Fs. I’m talking about the complete and utter morons. I’m talking about the stumped-for-an-answer-when-you-say-hello type of idiot. I know that this sounds harsh, but if you think your son might actually be a stupid idiot – just get it over with and call the cops. Tough love people.


I’m not suggesting that we pre-judge. I took advantage of a rare opportunity to conduct this research and now I’m sharing it with you. For me, only one of the above held true – I think.

Wednesday, February 03, 2010

You Might Be A Criminal If...

The National Association of Certified Fraud Examiners (ACFE) compiled a list of behavioral red flags from almost 1,000 case studies. Their research indicates that, to varying degrees, these behaviors were present in the fraud cases that they studied. If you exhibit some or all of these behaviors, you just might be a would-be felon.

Use your best Jeff Foxworthy voice and say each one of these aloud to see if they apply to you. Start by saying, "If you (insert red flag), you might be a criminal."

* are living beyond your means
* have financial difficulties
* have a wheeler-dealer attitude
* have problems with control issues and are unwilling to share duties
* have had a divorce or other family problems
* have an unusually close association with vendor/customer
* are irritable, suspicious or defensive
* have addiction problems
* have past legal problems
* have past employment-related problems
* complain about inadequate pay
* refuse to take vacations
* have excessive pressure from within your organization
* your life circumstances are unstable
* have excessive family or peer pressure for success
* complain about lack your of authority
* have a roommate named Bubba

Ok, now take it easy, that last one was mine. These are red flags only! The ACFE is a great organization - I've had a chance to speak at a few of their events and have met some of their members. They have unbelievable training and resources.

To see the ACFE 2008 Report to the Nation, go here.

Monday, December 14, 2009

Contributors to the Junk Mortgage Market

In James Doran’s article in this morning’s National he makes reference to the "worse than junk" [mortgage] loans that were taken out by people who couldn't repay them. This portion of the article is worth expanding upon.

Some would have us believe that these loans existed because lenders' loan programs allowed for practically anyone with a heart beat to get a loan. This, however, is only part of the truth.

While the loan program guidelines were lenient, many of those in charge of enforcing the lending guidelines, or the loan originators) were negligent and reckless in their administration of them. The stated income loan for example, was insane from the standpoint of a secure investment but to many loan officers offering this loan to their would-be customers, it was a dream come true. It was often referred to as a "liar loan." Stated income - meaning you didn't have to provide any documentation to back up your statement of your own income.

In heated debates with loan officers I would often defend that just because the customer didn’t have to prove their income didn’t mean that they could lie about it. The general attitude was of the flavor, “Well, if they’re not going to ask for proof, what do you THINK they [the lenders] expect from us.” Which is sad since the statement implies that dishonesty from a loan officer is something that can be expected.

I’ll take this moment to state that I do not view all loan officers or mortgage originators as dishonest. Most of them that I’ve met in my nearly 20 years in this profession have been nothing but honest and professional.

That said, I don’t think that the origination of the loan products with the seemingly lax guidelines can be ignored as a contributing factor in the sub-prime problems of this decade.

Thursday, October 15, 2009

Fraud Story

It's still happening! Even after all the news about fraud, loan originators are still willing to "bend" the guidelines.

I won't say who, but I am helping a couple of friends understand the process of obtaining a loan - as they go through it. We'll call the first one Jack. Jack owns his home free and clear. He has no provable income so he needed a co-borrower/co-signer. A friend of ours, we'll call her Paula (she does not live at Jack's house) agreed to co-sign on a home equity loan.

Let's get a bit of history first.

Jack (a non-banker, real estate, mortgage or finance guy) originally applied for the loan, by himself. He was told by his banker that he could get a loan - no problem.

First of all, this advice from his banker made no sense whatsoever. Jack is a great guy, decent credit, decent assets, but no income. By the way, the banker I am referring to works for the 6th largest bank in the country. They do not have a loan program for people with no provable income.

But when Jack hears his banker tell him that he would have no problem getting a loan on the home that he owns free and clear, Jack gets excited - of course. So Jack fills out the loan application.

The banker submits the loan. I have no idea what the banker listed as income on the application, but Jack certainly didn't lie and say that he had income, because he doesn't. Jack doesn't know enough about the loan guidelines to lie about income.

Response came back from the underwriters; they needed clarification on a few things. They saw a foreclosure listed from back in 2000.

Check back to read about the conclusion.